Showing posts with label tenv. Show all posts
Showing posts with label tenv. Show all posts

Sunday, March 18, 2012

Why Canadians do not move north

A Passage from Grey Owl's "The Men of the Last Frontier."

 

At the Wainfleet Library a few months ago, Tommy and I saw a report by an explorer and local boy. He just got back from exploring for the first time a river that runs into James Bay. In his canoe, alone, he floated by a polar bear. I was inspired by this presentation to buy and read his book about his first expedition to northern Ontario that he made as a teen. Most of this province in the north is a huge swamp, second only to the Amazon as an unexplored vastness. He tells of how he was inspired by the books of Grey Owl, one of the first environmentalist writers.

I happened to have Grey Owl's first book, "The Men of the Last Frontier," in my library, and this prompted me to read it. Here is a passage from that book explaining why this bush country is so tough, why it has never been colonized. If you ever wondered why Canadians hug our Southern Border, or why we do not have large cities in the far north as do the Russians, here is as good an explanation as any I have seen. Needless to say, this author is speaking from direct, personal experience living in this terrible (for humans) wasteland.

 

clip_image001

 

 

Chapter Two; The Land of Shadows

 

In the fastness of this rapidly fading frontier, the last on this continent, reigns the Spirit of the North Land. … Through them the invader must pick his way with the delicacy and assurance of one who walks barefoot amongst naked knives. Some of his weapons are merely annoyances, irritating but bearable; others are harassing to the point of obsession, wearing out the body and mind, and lessening the resisting power of a man; others, yet, bring swift death, or the long slow agonies of those who would die but cannot.

 

A stiff, wiry growth of sage brush, knee-deep and tangled, cumbers the ground over large areas. Mosquitoes, black flies, moose flies, and sand flies in relentless swarms make the forest almost uninhabitable for three months of the four of which the summer consists. The immense inland seas, shallow and exposed, are frequently whipped to fury on short notice, or none at all, by terrific storms, which, gathering force over the height of land, lash these northern latitudes with unbelievable fury. Forest fires, irresistible, all-devouring, sweep at times through the close-set resinous timber at railroad speed, leaving in their wake a devastation of bare hills and smoking stumps; desperate indeed is the plight of the voyageur so trapped far from water. Frequently miles of rapids have to be negotiated, where only the greatest skill and courage, coupled with days at a time of heart-breaking and exhausting labour, can gain the objective.

 

clip_image002

 

 

In winter snow often lies six feet deep in the woods and at the railroad, a hundred or so miles to the south, sixty-five degrees below zero (Fahrenheit) is no uncommon temperature. A rise in temperature often precipitates a blizzard, and these winter storms are so violent as to destroy whole areas of timber by sheer weight alone; the solitary trapper caught on the trail by one of these tempests, with little or no warning, especially if crossing any large lake, is in grave danger. His dogs, blinded and half-choked by the wind-driven masses of snow, cannot face the storm. Himself unable to break trail through the mounting drifts, or to keep his direction through the whirling white wall that surrounds him at the distance of a few feet, he may, if far from land, perish miserably.

 

Perhaps, wisely relying on his dogs to lead him ashore, he may, if lucky, find wood and shelter enough for his protection. A broken axe handle under these conditions would be not only an inconvenience, but a disaster with probably fatal results. Here, with his toboggan sheet for a windbreak, a bed of hastily laid brush, and a pile of wood sufficient to do all night, gathered with infinite labour, he can make some kind of a stand to live out the storm.

 

The howling wind fills his shelter with blinding smoke, and the fire only serves to melt the snow as it accumulates on blankets, food and clothing, wetting everything; cooking is impossible, and content with a pail of tea and perhaps some thawed-out fish intended for dog feed, he and his shivering huskies crouch by the fire all the long night. And often enough the cold light of morning breaks on a Shelter half-filled with drifting snow, a fire long since extinguished, and a pack of whining wolf-dogs waiting in vain to be harnessed up, later to run wild with the wolves.

 

From Grey Owl, The Men of the Last Frontier, Macmillan, Toronto, 1931, pages 35-37

This book can be downloaded at: http://www.archive.org/details/menofthelastfron013925mbp

Saturday, September 04, 2010

What Choosing Life Really Means

September 04, 2010


This is a rewrite of an early chapter in the infrastructure section of Citizens Without Borders



Progress in Nature and Culture



By John Taylor; 2010 Sep 04, Asma 15, 167 BE



My ten-year-old son requested that I read the Book of Genesis as part of our daily study session. I had read the book before of course, silently, but never aloud to an audience unfamiliar with the text. I was quite surprised at their reaction to that obscure passage between Eden and the advent of Noah with that seemingly endless list of prodigiously long-lived and long-named patriarchs, each living for an age and then dropping out with the formula, "...and then he died." My small audience reacted with increasing puzzlement, then hilarity at the glum quietus each suffered. Humour is not something I expected to find in Genesis; it sounds like material for somebody's Ph.D. thesis...



Increase is a Meter of Obedience



Another surprise on this reading was that the formula, "be fruitful and multiply" is not confined to one passage, it is repeated throughout Genesis. God says it at the first creation, Eden, and at the second creation, after Noah. It goes out at the start of every revelation. It surely led to the principle that Baha'is call "universal education."



Some Biblical translations say, "Be fruitful and increase in number," since the mathematical idea of multiplication is a recent development. But even if it somehow did mean "multiply," God was pointing to nature in general, not to exploding the human population until ecosystems collapse and all die together. That would hardly be increase, would it? Surely what is meant is the reverse of our cancerous increase at all costs. If so, Genesis is talking about what biology now calls "species diversity," as well as what is called "biomass," the total weight of living creatures.



Saving the Oceans



I just listened to a distressing new TED speech about the harm that we are doing to the world's oceans through neglect, overfishing and pollution. The talk took place before the BP oil disaster in the Gulf of Mexico, so it is worse now. It struck me even harder how unjust it is for some to place the blame for all this frenetic destruction on the divine dictum. God is pointing right at nature, He is telling us to take it upon ourselves to see that nature prospers.



The implication is that the number of plants and animals acts as an indicator of whether we are corrupt or pure in our obedience to God. God ended the first creation with a flood because, God asserts, men had become "corrupt." As this oceanographer points out in his speech, we have dredged the sea bottom to the point where over huge areas the beautiful coral now literally looks brown, like some desolate farmer's plowed field. If the land under the seas were visible as the land is to us, we would be very afraid. We have done all we could to destroy the oceans, in disobedience of divine decree.



High Surface Area Natural Spaces



Let us be optimistic. It would not be too difficult to reverse our disobedience of God's first command, to be fruitful and multiply.



The cosmopolitan condition would make it simple to reverse the depredation of the oceans. We could start by ending the corrupt subsidies that Portugal and other small countries hand out to their fishermen to underwrite dredging operations on the sea bottom. We could halt other maritime disasters as well, like ending offshore drilling for oil. By electrifying industry we would not need super tankers to ship oil around the world, ending the danger of oil spills. By switching to organic urbiculture we would end the growing dead zones caused by runoff of agricultural chemicals.



Aside from ending destructive policies, there are many positive measures that we could then take to obey God's command to increase biomass and undersea species diversity



Divers have long observed that sunken ships vastly increase the number of plants and fish just by increasing the available surface area. Wrecks and uneven ground provide hiding places for many plants, herbivores and carnivores. Artificial reefs could be built by dumping decommissioned ships and just about any other large object into coastal areas. In places where this has been tried, both species diversity and the harvest from coastal fisheries increased dramatically. With a world government this could be done on a much larger scale.



One recent proposal is to use sand structures. Researchers, including Jason De Jong at the Soil Interactions Laboratory, at UC Davis (http://www.sil.ucdavis.edu/people-jason.htm) and Stefano Ciurli of the University of Bologna have discovered that a common swamp bacterium, Bacillus Pasteurii, can initiate a biochemical reaction that changes sand into sandstone in as little as twenty-four hours. Amazingly, a sort of three-dimensional printer directed by CAD/CAM software can direct these bacteria to sculpt sand dunes into any shape they please. Magnus Larsson (http://www.magnuslarsson.com/architecture/dune.asp) has proposed that this technique be used in the Green Wall Sahara initiative, a shelterbelt of trees that is being planted across twenty-four African countries in order to hold back the spread of the Sahara. The technique may be adapted to the formation of artificial reefs as well. It would make it cheap and easy to form the sea floor into whatever surface oceanographers deem most likely propagate life under the waves.



So, instead of subsidizing fishermen to destroy the oceans, why not hire the same workers to sail along the coasts of every continent in super tankers full of sand, dumping behind huge artificial structures that sink onto the sea floor to form artificial reefs. After plying the seas this way for a few years, who knows how much biomass the oceans would support?



And why confine ourselves to the seas?



We could enlist these sandstone manufacturing bacteria to create habitats with vastly greater surface area than is usually found in nature. That way we could turn boring prairies into hilly, sculpted surfaces of whatever shape ecologists deem desirable for species diversity. With research and experience, we could replenish natural areas that now are languishing. In fact, we could probably actually create greater biomass and biodiversity than before humans took over.


More is understood now about the importance of fungi as the foundation of forest ecosystems. Armed with this knowledge, we could sculpt the forest floor specifically for the support of mushrooms and other fungi. This would make trees stronger and healthier, and supercharge the number and diversity of species living in the forest.



This way we could fulfill the prime divine order, to multiply the fruits of nature. But why restrict ourselves to nature? Christ's parable of the talents intensified the first commandment, shifting it to the human world. The parable implies that God not only gets quite irate when we fail to multiply natural diversity, He is also less than pleased when we neglect to develop our human talent as well.



Human Diversity



In order to increase human diversity, we could mix cities with supercharged rural and natural areas. Done wisely, this would increase the fruitfulness of both the human and the natural world at once. For example, occasional exposure to nature has a healing effect on the human psyche. Studies show that a five minute walk in a forest path while in conversation or solving a puzzle has a more powerful effect on our well-being than a dose of antidepressant. Hospital patients who convalesce in natural surroundings heal much faster than those in an artificial environment. By mixing nature into all landscapes we would increase human happiness to heights never before attained.


::

Friday, July 30, 2010

My Big Fat Tax

Fat, Climate and Farming


By John Taylor; 2010 July 30, Kalimat 17, 167 BE


==========
In this posting:


Fat Taxes
No Change in Climate Change
Local Farming Initiative
==========




Fat Taxes




Consider this news item:




"Leading British doctors will urge the UK government Monday to impose a `fat tax' on junk food and introduce cigarette-style warnings to children about the dangers of poor diets and products high in fat, salt or sugar. [an expert says that] ... the consumption of unhealthy food should be seen to be just as damaging as smoking or binge drinking. `Thirty years ago, it would have been inconceivable to have imagined a ban on smoking in the workplace or in pubs, and yet that is what we have now, are we willing to be just as courageous in respect of obesity? I would suggest that we should be.' The doctors are also demanding a tough government action plan to stop fast-food chains opening outlets near schools, restrict the advertising of products high in fat, salt or sugar, and limit sponsorship of sports events by fast-food companies such as McDonald's." (British docs demand 'fat tax' on junk food http://www.torontosun.com/news/world/2010/07/11/14679421.html)




Also suggested were "fast food free zones" in city planning, and a ban on advertising of garbage foods -- indeed, it occurs to me, why not force them to call a spade a spade on their labels? Why not stick a big warning label on the front: "This food is rated 8 out 10 on the garbage food scale of the World Dietician's Association."


A fat tax would hardly be popular with the public, especially now that the majority in Western nations are obese themselves -- or should I say, ourselves, since I am a good fifty pounds overweight. Few politicians, therefore, would dare touch this issue, urgent as it may be. I must think differently from most fatties, since I look down at my ugly waistline and dream of an economy where sweet and sugary food was expensive and good food was cheap.




No Change in Climate Change




Nor are things going well in the climate change department, also an urgent priority. The obvious policy change would be to impose a carbon tax, but again, any new tax would be unpopular. The U.S. government just effectively rejected any serious action against carbon emissions. In his NY Times column, economist Paul Krugman explains why,




"So it was not the science, the scientists, or the economics that killed action on climate change. What was it? The answer is, the usual suspects: greed and cowardice. If you want to understand opposition to climate action, follow the money. The economy as a whole would not be significantly hurt if we put a price on carbon, but certain industries above all, the coal and oil industries would. And those industries have mounted a huge disinformation campaign to protect their bottom lines."


"Look at the scientists who question the consensus on climate change; look at the organizations pushing fake scandals; look at the think tanks claiming that any effort to limit emissions would cripple the economy. Again and again, you will find that they are on the receiving end of a pipeline of funding that starts with big energy companies, like Exxon Mobil, which has spent tens of millions of dollars promoting climate-change denial, or Koch Industries, which has been sponsoring anti-environmental organizations for two decades. Or look at the politicians who have been most vociferously opposed to climate action. Where do they get much of their campaign money? You already know the answer. (http://www.nytimes.com/2010/07/26/opinion/26krugman.html?_r=2&th&emc=th)




Krugman rightly points out what the real cause of this dithering is: attachment to ideology. Even when it becomes self-contradictory to the point of absurdity, the rich cling to their shibboleths,




"It has always been funny, in a gallows humor sort of way, to watch conservatives who laud the limitless power and flexibility of markets turn around and insist that the economy would collapse if we were to put a price on carbon. All serious estimates suggest that we could phase in limits on greenhouse gas emissions with at most a small impact on the economy's growth rate."




This is why I think that the next Einstein will not be a physicist but an accountant or game designer. Not even an economist, but a genius with numbers who can make the numbers vivid using charts, displays and incentives.




A Local Farming Initiative




I recently bought a "share" in a cooperative farming effort called "Shared Harvests," pushed largely by a local farmer and a local physician, Reza Kazemi (an Iranian Muslim). It costs twenty five bucks to get a basket full of produce every week. I blanched at the price of what I was getting, but Reza pointed out that the group is called, "Triple Bottom Line for Sustainability Inc.," -- you have to write it all out on every check -- because as consumers we have to be aware when we are paying for something that the money should go to those who produce it, that there are three bottom lines, "financial, environmental and social responsibility and sustainability." I still blanched at what I was getting for what I had paid, but my responsibility self-image rose a little.


I got my first "share" of produce last week and was forced to do something with a big batch of kale, which I had only seen in cans before that. I steamed it up and it kept me in meals for a few days. It was good soaked with olive oil. Since I eat two cobs of microwaved corn every day, I held my cob of corn over the kale and soaked it in the extra olive oil. Here are some interesting facts extracted from their newsletter,




"There is a farm income crisis happening in North America. Farmers on average have been earning incomes below the poverty line for 15 of the last 20 years according to the National Farmers Union. The average age of a farmer in Canada is 52.6 and increasing yearly and the family farm is decreasing at a rapid rate. These are troubling facts, endangering the very existence of rural communities that have relied on small family farms for its sustainability and prosperity. It also endangers our food security. ... millions of Canadians including many of us in Dunnville spend long hours and resources caring for our grass instead of growing food; and millions of tons of local food perish due to lack of manpower to harvest it!"


::

Wednesday, May 05, 2010

An Offshore Disaster

My response to the Gulf of Mexico oil well disaster
  


The headlines have been the same over the past few weeks: an offshore oil well exploded and is now gushing great gobs of Texas Tea into the Gulf of Mexico. The perpetrator? BP Oil Company. Heroically, Gulf Oil is building a giant cone or dome to siphon off the spurting crude. They just managed to cap one of the three leaks miles deep under the waves.

Meanwhile, locals in a boat just saw a sea turtle swimming through the crud, obviously distressed. Not being trained in animal rescue, they could only stand by helplessly. Get ready for lots more helpless hand-wringing as the images of other victims, bird, animal and human, start coming in.

No crime has been nearly as bad as this one in the U.S., ever. This oil well already qualifies as the worst industrial and environmental accident in the U.S. in history, and it has just begun. Judging by past precedent, the company is certain to get away with this. After all, Exxon slipped free of the massive destruction that the crash of its tanker the Exxon Valdez did to Alaska in the 1980's. The headlines declared in big letters that they had lost a court case and were slapped with an impressive amount of punitive damages. Then a little while later a tiny headline whispered that the damages had been reduced to a slap on the wrist. Companies with that much money can keep the law and politics in their back pocket. Worse, BP is not even an American company. Its huge wealth is beyond the world's most powerful nation's power to touch or regulate.

Authorities are responding to this disaster in accordance with state-corporatist ideology. The American president rushed to the distressed company's bedside, offering to hold its hand, assuring the industry that he will defend the unalienable right of Big Oil to drill for more crude off American coasts. He made it clear that he stands ready to protect these corporations from the dire danger of a public backlash.

I wonder what the response would be if the world had a government and a court. I love to fantasize about how events might play out. First of all, no company, no matter how international or complex, could go the authority of a world government. How about this scenario:

A world government's first step would be simply to disband BP Oil. Take it and all of its parent and subsidiary companies, and kill it. This is something that would never happen in the U.S. right now. No company has been broken up by a American government on any level for at least thirty years, even the most egregiously criminal. But as I say, no crime can equal this one.

There would be no need for a trial, the world government would just end the company's corporate charter and freeze its bank accounts. For the past couple of centuries, corporations have fought for and won most of the rights that humans enjoy; it is only right that they should be subject to the sanctions that humans suffer when they do great wrongs.

Consider this. It seems fair and right murderers should be kept a long time on death row, in case of a mistake. But why be so hesitant to do that to an abstract entity like a corporation? When a company commits a crime there is no need for delay or court cases, a responsible authority would disband it forthwith. Nobody dies, no blood is shed. A few careers are interrupted, but involvement in misbehaviour on this scale would, or should, end such a career anyway.

A world government with the authority to summarily execute corporations would command more respect than the fawning lickspittles that supposedly regulate them now. It would set an example by immediately selling off BP's assets and allocating the money to repair the damage their crimes have done to the environment and smaller, honest companies who are suffering from this act, such as fishermen. If any funds remain after the cleanup from BP's present assets of some 242 billion dollars (<http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=assets+of+bp+>), use them to mitigate the damage that the oil industry as a whole is doing to the environment.

If none of this sends a chill through the industry, go ahead and jail BP's board of directors, CEO and entire upper management. They jailed Nazi's in the Nuremberg Trials, didn't they? If you walk through a store and you take a stick of gum, they will jail you, won't they? Why should far worse crimes than shoplifting hide behind a corporation's veil of immunity?

The burning of carbon is a sunset industry anyway, so any shock that these measures do to the economy can only be for the good. Let the wealth of BP and its cronies be given as grants for building offshore wind turbines. Renewable electric power facilities are inherently safer, anyway. An offshore wind turbine may fall over in a storm, but the damage would be nothing compared to an uncapped oil well.


::

Thursday, April 01, 2010

All Fool's Day Article

Today is Our Day!

By John Taylor; 2010 April 01, Ala' 12, 166 BE

(Written in Hamilton, around the 26th of March, 1990)


In late fall, Christians celebrate those who have attained pre-eminence in morality, the saints, with "All Saints Day." Here in North America we know this celebration better by a demonic evening before All Saints Day. This time when demons have their hour has become the secular celebration of morbidity, Halloween. In early spring we celebrate the mirror reverse of All Saints Day, what is called in England "All Fool's Day."

You and I may never be called saints but it is fair to bet that every one of us will make a fool of ourselves sometime or other.
So, April Fools is our day!

Let us not fritter the occasion away on mindless practical jokes. All fools day is our chance to reflect upon human folly and its reverse, wisdom.
It has always been in the interest of society to condemn folly. For while a fool may or may not suffer from his folly, those around him always do! Mockery helps reduce foolish behaviour.

But social pressure is not enough to make a fool into a prudent person. Worse, when walking across thin ice, it is never wise to turn and laugh if the person next to us falls through. Even as we mock, the cracks beneath our feet grow larger.

Some may call it the height of folly for the captain of a super tanker to get stewed to the gills before setting off to sea, or for a judge to sentence him only to a maximum thirty days in prison, or for American corporations and policy makers to have created this environmental time bomb in the first place.
But the great losers from the Exxon Valdez are also the greatest fools, those we honour today: all of us.

Do we not all watch helplessly as the Amazonian rain forest goes up in flames, as the developed world competes with the undeveloped world to see whether automobile fumes or wood smoke will be the fastest to strangle the air we breathe?

Is not the definition of a fool one who rejects a clear and simple solution and persists in what makes the problem worse?

"As a dog," the Bible says, "returneth to his vomit, so a fool returneth to his folly." (Prov 26:11) Repeatedly this century our leaders have rejected a world government and insisted that world problems can be solved on a national level. In a planet that is already a single economic unit corporations, with nothing powerful enough to police them -- not even the superpowers -- have become destructive to their own and everyone else's interests. It is natural, though irresponsible, for a few leaders to want to be big fish in little ponds; but for public opinion to tolerate collective suicide for the sake of massaging a few egos, what else can that be but folly?


:

Saturday, March 20, 2010

local kitchens and gardens


  

Block Kitchens for Avoiding Sin


By John Taylor; 2010 March 20, Ala' 19, 166 BE


My mother taught us that waste is a sin. In fact, her generation had lived through the depression, and they were very economical by today's standards. If she was right about the sin of waste, then the reverse must be true: any measure that gets rid of waste in our infrastructure has to be virtuous to the point of saintliness.

Bearing my upbringing in mind, one of the goads that prompted me to think through the idea of hillside housing was a report of a study in Sweden that found shocking levels of food waste by the average household. A great proportion of the fresh vegetables that are purchased rot in the refrigerator, even in well run homes (do not even get me started on poorly run ones, like ours). Another study, using more accurate measures, just discovered that the waste is even worse than I had imagined, and that it is built into the very structure of the capitalist economy.


"There are reports of rich countries throwing out 25-30% of what is bought. Add in what never even makes it to the cupboard or the refrigerator, and the scale of the problem is considerably larger. [the study found that] ... the average American wastes 1,400 kilocalories a day. That amounts to 150 trillion kilocalories a year for the country as a whole -- about 40% of its food supply, up from 28% in 1974. Producing these wasted calories accounts for more than one-quarter of America's consumption of freshwater, and also uses about 300m barrels of oil a year. On top of that, a lot of methane (a far more potent greenhouse gas than carbon dioxide) emerges when all this food rots." (A hill of beans; America's food-waste problem is getting worse," The Economist, Nov 28, 2009, p. 94)


The present economy specializes in making food cheap, but the result is that people are tempted to gorge it all down (I am guilty of this: the quickest way of avoiding wasted food is to eat it, resulting in gluttony -- I calculated this morning that I am carrying around more fat than my ten year old son presently weighs, eighty pounds; I tried lifting him and could barely do it), and retailers find it more economical to just throw out food that is not bought at the end of the day. The waste is horrendous.


"Such supply-chain waste can be built into the price, and usually makes economic sense. Throwing away leftovers is often better business than risking running out of stock." (Id.)


Another study found that cooking smells, traditional and enticing as they may be, contain surprising amounts of gases, volatile organic compounds and other toxic materials. There has to be a better way to deliver food, thought I. Why not eliminate the kitchen in the home completely?
Surely, it would be possible to have a large kitchen in every neighbourhood that quickly prepares and efficiently delivers hot meals to houses nearby on demand. Such a community kitchen would be large enough that higher codes and standards would be enforceable. Waste is minimized, food remainders composted, and cooking smells properly contained. As a bonus, it could be run cooperatively, offering both professional employment opportunities as well as a chance for amateurs to participate in exchange for a reduction in their food bill. Such a cooperative block kitchen would offer neighbours a chance to socialize, rather like the building bees that the pioneers held in earlier centuries.

Indeed, the tendency for women to use such gatherings not only to prepare food but also to organize and uphold their rights is probably a major reason why separate kitchens were maintained so strictly by the old patriarchal order. Now corporations have co-opted home cooking with factory supplied meals. Almost two generations of mothers have forgotten how to cook for themselves, and as a result we are suffering an epidemic of obesity, cancer and heart disease.
A similar inter-generational loss of knowledge is happening with farming. Now that less than two percent of the population are farmers, we are in danger of forgetting not only how to prepare food, but to grow it too. Having growing know-how concentrated into so few hands is extremely dangerous; the slightest disaster could wipe out the few growers and threaten our very survival.

Once again, the idea of neighbourhood-level organization seems to be the answer. Just combine the block kitchen with a kitchen garden, or even a small community farm. Even if no land is available, windows can be used to grow leafy vegetables, packed with Omega 3's, which nutritionists tell us is what we all need most for a healthy diet. With cooperative gardening combined with cooperative farming, the greens served by the block kitchen will always be as local and fresh as possible. Having a larger proportion of the population directly involved in urban agriculture will spread the experience around, increasing the stability and security of all.





:

Solar Cooking

 I am interested in figuring out how to do a solar stir fry.

Friday, March 19, 2010

Enter Hopefully



  

Whenever an environmentalist opens his mouth, no matter what he thinks he is saying people take the message to be like what was posted over the door to Hades: "Abandon Hope All Ye That Enter Here." This was just what renowned environmental broadcaster David Suzuki found out to his chagrin when he interviewed his daughter (this, I hear from friends, is the subject of a documentary series being shown on CBC). All her life she had listened to her father going on about the decline of nature. He had imagined that he was being upbeat, but no. She told him that all she had got out of what he had been telling her about the urgency of saving the environment all those years was just that we should give up hope, since we are all hurtling to hell in a hand basket. David Suzuki protested vehemently, "That is not at all what I wanted you to think!" I must say I find Suzuki's voice and demeanour reassuring, even to the point of being mesmerizing. He cannot be faulted for a gloomy aspect. But his beloved environment is in trouble, and I think I am not the only one who finds it depressing to hear about it.

After talking to his daughter, Suzuki subsequently researched the solutions and wrote at least one book about answers to the problem. His daughter is now an environmental writer and broadcaster in her own right.

This is one reason I am writing People Without Borders. When I did come across Suzuki's book of solutions in the library and glanced through it I was almost as saddened by it than his earlier, darker writing. These so-called solutions, helpful as they may be in their own context, are not going to put a dent in the rumbling juggernaut of total planetary destruction. We need far more fundamental changes than having dry cleaners switch from one chemical to another.
 
Consider, if you will, the special report in the latest Scientific American, "Managing Earth's Future; Solutions for a Finite World." The editors sum up the first article, "Boundaries for a Healthy Planet," (Jonathan Foley, SA, April, 2010, p. 54) saying,


"Although climate change gets ample attention, species loss and nitrogen pollution exceed safe limits by greater degrees. Other environmental processes are also headed toward dangerous levels."


The author of the article shows a lovely graphic of the results of a major study by a group of scientists, reported in Nature. The chart looks like a spider splattered over a wall clock, displaying nine factors threatening our survival and how close each is to bursting beyond the earth's natural limit. Only two, nitrogen and biodiversity, have blown well past the line, though one, CO2, is also slightly over the line. In a hopeful turn, they also concentrate on solutions, such as they are. The editors sum them up:


"Promptly switching to low-carbon energy sources, curtailing land clearing and revolutionizing agricultural practices are crucial to making human life on Earth more sustainable."


For the moment, let us assume that this approach is sufficient. The question remains, how do we do it? Governments go hat in hand to energy companies, not the other way around. Curtailing land clearing would require an overhaul of the economy and the entire legal system that supports it. And agriculture? Nationalist states are nominally democratic but voters are not represented proportionally. Rural voters dominate urban ones. As a result, politicians routinely bribe farmers with subsidies in order to get re-elected.

Changes to any of these are simply not negotiable.

The only hope for change is a major overhaul not only of democracy and education, but also of the very ethical and religious reflexes of the human race. How do you do that?





:

Tuesday, December 22, 2009

Why did Copenhagen Fail?

One of Monbiot's best essays so far:

Requiem for a Crowded Planet 

http://www.monbiot.com/archives/2009/12/21/requiem-for-a-crowded-planet/?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=email
 





::

Wednesday, December 16, 2009

One Degree Matters

One Degree Matters Hi-Resolution from aceandace on Vimeo.




Full documentary film available at:

One degree matters

'One degree matters' follows social and business leaders as they travel to Greenland and experience for themselves the dramatic effects of the melting of the ice cap and come to understand the planetary effects of climate change and the impacts these will have on society and the economy. The film brings to the screen the latest science from the Arctic and shows why a further rise in global temperature of one degree matters for the future of humankind. Film had premiere: 13 December 2009 during COP15.

Sunday, December 13, 2009

Hard Nobel Truths

Pulverizing a Hard Truth


By John Taylor; 2009 Dec 13, Masa'il 02, 166 BE


"We must begin by acknowledging the hard truth: We will not eradicate violent conflicts in our lifetimes. There will be times when nations -- acting individually or in concert -- will find the use of force not only necessary but morally justified." (President Obama, accepting the Nobel Peace Prize. The day after the speech it was the quote of the day for the New York Times.)

This truth, if it be such, is hard indeed. The ice caps are melting and sea levels rising, but this truth remains immovable and unquestioned by those with real power. Yet there lies behind it an even harder truth: as long as the lion's share of the world's wealth is squandered on weaponry to defend nations from one another and, failing that excuse, from terrorists, there will never be enough money to retool, de-carbonize and defend our planet from the hydra's heads that threaten it from all sides. As long as this hard truth is unbroken, the Nobel Peace Prize, or any talk of peace at all, will be an empty sham. Until we break down such stumbling blocks to world government in our minds, there will be no hope for Kyoto, for Copenhagen, or ultimately for any of us.


Somehow we must soften and break the world's hard, ugly truths before we break our heads on them.


A week before Obama's speech, a well-known historian, James Bradley, wrote an insightful editorial in the NY Times describing what was going on behind the scenes when the first U.S. President to win the Nobel Peace, Teddy Roosevelt, earned the prize (Diplomacy That Will Live in Infamy, James Bradley, December 6, 2009; Theodore Roosevelt, not F.D.R., had a greater effect on Japans decision to attack Pearl Harbor. http://www.nytimes.com/2009/12/06/opinion/06bradley.html). To sum it up briefly, Bradley wondered why his father, a marine, had to fight his Second World War in the Pacific, rather than Europe where one would have expected. As a historian it was not hard for Bradley to find out exactly why. Here is what happened.


A little over a century ago Theodore Roosevelt won his Nobel Peace Prize under false circumstances by taking credit for brokering the peace between Japan and Russia -- Baha'is are well familiar with this event, since the signing of the treaty took place at or nearby what is now Green Acre Baha'i Summer School. Roosevelt's acceptance of the prize was based on a lie, since it was Japan, not the U.S., which had secretly initiated the negotiations. If he had been honest he would have refused to accept the prize, but -- and here is another hard truth -- in an atmosphere of secrecy honest dealing is impossible. This historian traces the cause of Japan's attack on the U.S. at Pearl Harbor to Teddy Roosevelt's clear "You go, girl!" signal to Japan that her successful surprise attack on Russia, a clear violation of international law, was acceptable, even praiseworthy behaviour. Later, of course, the American role in the Second World War was shaped by Japan's attack on Pearl Harbor.


The second US president to win the Nobel Peace Prize was, ironically, the only one directly to take on the hard truth that Obama so frankly brought up in his Nobel acceptance speech. That was Woodrow Wilson. The hard truth almost literally broke his head, since he was impaired during the Paris peace talks, and eventually died of a brain aneurism. In ending World War One, Wilson valiantly set up the international organization that became known as the League of Nations but failed when his own senate refused to join the League. Wilson died a broken and disappointed man. Had he succeeded, there would have been no World War II, no Cold War, and we would have no problem averting pollution and the melting of the poles.


Clearly, Wilson was the only one of the first two presidents to deserve the Nobel. In fact, he was the only one to deserve the name "leader" or "statesman," since a leader by definition leads, he goes beyond past ways and presuppositions even in the face of disapproval. Roosevelt, like all heads of state under the hard rules of Realpolitik, was immune, out of reach of all law and morality. But imagine if he were not. Imagine what would happen to a beat cop if he witnessed a mugging, praised the mugger and helped him "make up" with his victim, and then went around pretending to be a peacemaker. He would be in jail, he would not be accepting prizes and commendations. But heads of state are beyond such restrictions.


Although Barak Obama is on record calling himself a world citizen, at least he is being clear about what that means for him. Is he taking Roosevelt's path over that of Wilson? Sometimes I think he is, sometimes not. I read that sentence over and over,


"There will be times when nations -- acting individually or in concert -- will find the use of force not only necessary but morally justified."


Sometimes this seems to state the obvious, that law and world order will have to be backed by force. But the next time I read it, it seems to be renouncing international law completely. Obama continued: "To say that force is sometimes necessary is not a call to cynicism - it is a recognition of history; the imperfections of man and the limits of reason." Hmm. When truth is that hard, it only makes sense that it should be caused by failings in our capacity to reason. Roosevelt was by this definition cynical, but at least he had the discretion to keep his contempt for international law a secret.


Just think, Germany in both wars, and Japan in the Second, and Russia in the Cold War, and Pol Pot, and just about any aggressor or villain you can name, all can just as candidly say that they "found the use of force not only necessary but morally justified." Osama Bin Laden, for heaven's sakes, finds force necessary and morally justified. Either you believe in law, a law that applies to all equally, or you do not. Otherwise we are all subject to "might makes right." This is the hard, indefeasible standard of naked self-interest that is openly being set on the table at Copenhagen.


::